0 My Basket

Electronic Cigarette Interview with Dr Joel Nitzkin

You must be over 18 to purchase products from ECigaretteDirect

Electronic Cigarette Interview with Dr Joel Nitzkin

About Dr. Joel Nitzkin

Dr. Joel Nitzkin is chair of the Tobacco Control Task Force for the American Association of Public Health Physicians. He kindly agreed to give us his expert opinion on e-cigarettes in this interview.

Joel Nitzkin

ECD: You have stated that based on available research e-cigarettes are far safer than cigarettes. How much safer are they, and how sure can we be of their relative safety?

Dr Nitzkin: There is no research per se on e-cigarettes. The safety information we have is on the delivery of nicotine for nicotine cessation and also on the safest of the tobacco products which basically deliver the same nicotine.
Now the safest of the tobacco products are what they call snus. And the literature on snus, which is evaluated on our website, basically shows that in the best of the epidemiological studies available today snus do not increase any cause of death. In other words, if there is a health hazard from snus it is smaller than can be measured with these studies. With that in mind we would figure that a tobacco

“…we have every reason to believe that the hazard posed by e-cigarettes would be much lower than one percent of the hazard posed by cigarettes.”

product that is delivered with just the nicotine and without any of the other toxic chemicals should be at least as safe.

So if we can figure that the nicotine in the e-cigarettes is basically a generic version of the same nicotine that is in prescription products, we have every reason to believe that the hazard posed by e-cigarettes would be much lower than one percent, probably lower than one tenth of one percent of the hazard posed by regular cigarettes.

ECD: I spoke to Ash UK and they said there hasn’t been enough research on e-cigarettes and that they haven’t been chemically tested.

Dr Nitzkin: Well, at least one manufacturer has been chemically tested. There are many different manufacturers of e-cigarettes…

One of the positive things we would hope would come out of FDA legislation would be requirements for quality assurances of manufacturing to make sure that the doses were accurate and to make that there aren’t contaminants that would increase the health risk. For example, many of these products have flavourings and I don’t know whether or not those flavourings might impose something of a risk. If they do I would think it would be small.

ECD: What research needs to be carried out into the use of the electronic cigarette?

Dr Nitzkin: Well, the first thing which I don’t really see as research is quality controlled assessment by an independent lab on an ongoing basis batch by batch to make sure that the chemical content is not contaminated by heavy metals or cancer causing substances. They would also need to make sure that the doses are accurate as stated.

Now there is a big difference of opinion in terms of what other research needs to be done. Those who oppose e-cigarettes and the entire family of alternative nicotine delivery devices express the view that to be sure they are safe there have to be tested and controlled clinical trials.

The problem with controlled and clinical trials is that it would be a physical impossibility to do that research. Why would it be physically impossible? Because it would involve recruiting a large number, probably several thousand, non-smokers, and then getting them to agree to be randomised into one or two or more groups. One of these groups would smoke cigarettes which clearly poses a severe health hazard, and others would test various smokeless products, including e-cigarettes.

Not only that, since these products are not being marketed for short term use of smoking cessation the study would probably have to run a decade or more to show if there are long term effects. Now such a study would cost tens of millions of dollars per product and basically costs aside it would be physically impossible to do. One of the reasons it would be physically impossible to do is that I don’t think you could ever recruit non-smokers to expose themselves to that sort of a risk and if you started with smokers you would have a residual risk from the smoking they had already done.

Number two, to be respectable you would probably have to hire an academic centre, preferably an American academic centre, to do this, and all American academic centres have what they call Institutional Review Boards that have to approve any research before it is done. And when you have research that has to be done that might pose a health risk to the research subjects but would be of no therapeutic value to the research subjects, their guidelines would prohibit them from approving such a study. That’s why I have made the statement, and I have tried to repeat the statement, that the testing guidelines that are built into the current draft of the FDA Tobacco bill would represent a defacto ban on the e-cigarettes.

They’ll say well, you can’t sell the cigarettes until you can show you have completed these studies to the satisfaction of the food and drug administration and if the studies are impossible to conduct you simply have the products banned. Period.

“…the testing guidelines that are built into the current draft of the FDA Tobacco bill would represent a defacto ban on the e-cigarettes.”

ECD: That wouldn’t just be the e-cigarettes, would it, it would be other alternative products…

Dr Nitzkin: E-Cigarettes, the sticks, the strips, the orbs, the snus, the camel, the Marlborough products and it would also relate to any other tobacco product that might be marketed as a lower risk or modified risk product.

Please note that comments of the interviewee do not necessarily represent the views of ECigaretteDirect.
Using this Interview – Anyone can use this interview: all we require is acknowledgement of this source and a link back to this site.

Continue Reading: Electronic Cigarette Interview with Dr Joel Nitzkin 1 2


Login To Your Account

If you have an account with us, please log in.

* Required Fields

Forgot Your Password?

You Must Be Over 18 to Buy From E-cigarette Direct

Why do I have to prove my age?

To our website you look under 18.

So, as a responsible retailer, we need to check your age.

You'll only need to do this once and it takes less than a minute.

Our age verification system is quick and easy to complete. Simply enter your date of birth, and our system will use the information from your order to do the rest.

On rare occasions, you might find that you don’t succeed on first try. Don’t worry - our super-friendly customer service team is on hand to ensure that, as long as you are 18 or over, you can still get your vaping supplies!

Once you have confirmed your age we won’t usually need to check again. (Exceptions can occur, for example if you change your name).

(You can help us check your age by ensuring your name and address are spelt absolutely correctly in the order form :) )

How your data is used

We use as little data as possible. The only data that ECigaretteDirect keep is information needed to send your order, and your date of birth (so we only have to check once!)

Your age is checked using Experian, which will check the information you provide against information in existing records to confirm you are over 18. No credit check is performed but a record of the search will be visible to you on your credit report. This will not affect your ability to get credit.

Why do we check age?

As you may know, there has been some concern that under-18’s may try vaping.

This is against both our company policy and the law.

And as responsible retailers, we need to do everything we can to ensure that every customer is of legal age.

For more information, see our Terms and Conditions.

How Secure is e-Cigarette Direct?

Your privacy is important to us, and your personal information should remain just that - personal.

See the little green lock in the search bar? That’s our security certificate (SSL or secure socket layer to be precise). It encrypts all the information you enter so that no-one else can see it.

Information you provide for age verification is sent securely to Experian and no details of the checks are stored in our system. Ever.

If you have any concerns, please call our friendly customer services team on 01792 852843 (Mon - Fri, 9am - 5pm).

For the techies: Our SSL certificate uses an sha256 hashing algorithm.